Quick, efficient decision making. Differences : Advantages And Disadvantages Of Athens And Sparta 857 Words | 4 Pages. ... What Are Advantages And Disadvantages Of Being A Sole Trader? However, some differences can be seen in cities such as Athens and Sparta. U.S. citizenship provides many advantages not available to green card holders.. Due to the political disorder that stemmed from the early dynastic activity, the emergence of the Han Dynasty (206 BCE- 228 CE) sprung to focus on restoring order. Slaves were the lowest class in Ancient Athens and, despite making up almost a third of the population of Athens, were treated as property and therefore had no political rights at all. These successes were driven, at least in part by the democracy’s success as a system of knowledge management: Athens did so well because the Athenians were able to innovate constantly, and yet were still able to reap the benefits of established and familiar ways of doing things. : The one with the superior technology, The Han Dynasty and the Roman Empire were two grand empires that rose out of preexisting territories and provided relative peace over wide areas. Citizens had rights which for the most part were limited only to themselves. Athenian society was a patriarchy; men held all rights and advantages, such as access to education and power. The first published picture of the Mandelbrot set. Was Alexander the Great Greek or Macedonian? Aristotle's definition, "a citizen pure and simple is defined by nothing else so much as by the right to participate in judicial functions and in office", highlights the main benefits of citizenship, participation in the commons. 3.1274b] But a state is a composite thing, in the same sense as any other of the things that are wholes but consist of many parts; it is therefore clear that we must first inquire into the nature of a citizen; for a state is a collection of citizens. It's not something that everyone across human history has had. Could own property, but could not vote or hold public office. about; we think the council made a perfectly reasonable judgment; and Was the Athenian generals' trial after Arginusae a political one? Are good pickups in a bad guitar worth it? Arbitrarily large finite irreducible matrix groups in odd dimension? The Athens lived by the Sea which was an advantage because they had an excellent trading system. Citizens in ancient Athens could only be a small part of the overall population. What evidence support the theory that the killing of unwanted children was practiced in ancient Athens? Each year 500 names were chosen from all the citizens of ancient Athens. Why does my cat lay down with me whenever I need to or I’m about to get up? stipend. Thus, all were equal (or nearly so) before the State’s needs and women had more freedom to move about. It only takes a minute to sign up. One may wonder, however, if Athenians were so keen to fight and die for the city, why conscription was necessary and why the topic of draft evasion crops up with some frequency in our sources. Responsibilities To become a U.S. citizen you must take the Oath of Allegiance. matter, the Athenians might say: We don't really have much to talk Athens had a geographic advantage because they were very superior. Athens and Sparta are the two famous city-states in Ancient Greece. Pol. What (in the US) do you call the type of wrench that is made from a steel tube? We can trace the concepts of citizenship back to ancient Greece. In the 4th century what was until then a practical limitation became law, as Demosthenes describes in Against Neaera: [Dem. They’re productive employees, business owners, artists, public servants, caregivers, and so on. Athenian Achievements in Classical Greece. In contrast, metics were required by law to have a guardian/sponsor that would stand for them, and failure to produce a guardian would mean they would lose their property and be sold as slaves. becoming a U.S. citizen is a way to demonstrate your commitment to your new country. Namely, a Citizen could own land, have heirs, own slaves, belong to the Assembly, and could have some political sway. The Athenian democracy provided a number of governmental resources to its population in order to encourage participation in the democratic process. As Felix Goldberg already mentioned, compensation for participating in the Boule was instituted in the mid 5th century, and Pericles' reforms allowed payment for jurors in the Ecclesia. I found this interview with historian Josiah Ober on the economy of ancient Greece, particularly Athens, interesting on many counts. Each of them had a distinct advantage that enabled them to defeat their enemies. It might perhaps be said that such persons are not officials at all, and that the exercise of these functions does not constitute the holding of office; and yet it is absurd to deny the title of official to those who have the greatest power in the state. Ironically, Pericles apparently pulled a few strings and managed to get his illegitimate son with his Milesian mistress, Aspasia, recognized as a citizen and as his heir. Can there be democracy in a society that cannot count? "In short, what was nominally a democracy became in his hands government by the first citizen.". Also, re: liturgies, surely it wasn't always voluntary. How to reveal a time limit without videogaming it? Who of the Athenians has advice to give? Once she gave birth, her father could not take her back. Citizens held power in some city-states, king or aristocrats in other. Read more. The historical record indicates that the Ancient Greeks fully believed that men were qualified to participate in the political process, despite the misgivings of some thinkers such as Plato. The remaining residents/citizens were called plebians, representing the poor as well as many of the city’s wealthy. The readings from Homer, Xenophon, Aristophanes, and Thucydides explain the Greek ideals about heroism. PC ATX12VO (12V only) standard - Why does everybody say it has higher efficiency? what were some of the achievements of the golden age of athens? so they would pass it by acclimation. Those 500 citizens had to actively serve in the government for one year. Not to lecture you or anything, but it is a big deal. Athenian citizenship was only for one class or group in their society; citizens. The Athens lived by the Sea which was an advantage because they had an excellent trading system. Throughout the Greek world at this time, a great period of expansion and colonization took place, chiefly due to land hunger. For example, a citizen had the right to bring a … I'm under the impression that metics were only allowed to rent farmland from citizens, but I'm not 100% sure on that. that what we should be discussing is, you know, the war orphan Good citizens share their skills, talents, and abilities with others. Hidden Benefits. A citizen pure and simple is defined by nothing else so much as by the right to participate in judicial functions and in office. Hetairai were well-educated courtesans who were courted for both beauty and intelligence. Citizenship in the Early Republic. And being a citizen often meant being subject to the city's law in addition to having power in some instances to help choose officials. For the sake of distinction therefore let us call the combination of the two functions ‘office’ without limitation. From the transcript: Athenians, would be called in the center of the main city of Athens. The Romans were one of the first civilizations to have written rights for its citizens. the president and allowed to speak for as long as they were relevant. The city-state of Athens had citizens, which no other place had, but the citizens of ancient Athens were only males over the age of eighteen and their parents, grandparents, and sometimes even great-grandparents had to be born in Athens. Compensation for participating in assemblies was indeed Pericles' idea (or at least it started during his time). Didge Doo answered . Being a citizen of Rome Paul was able to use his rights and privileges to his advantage when dealing with the Roman authorities. Both land ownership in Ancient Athens and liturgies would make excellent questions by themselves, I got a bit carried on in this answer and actually skipped the more relevant paragraph (updating now). 6000 - 8000 of them did come to the assembly -- to debate what they should There were two types of drama in Greece: tragedy and comedy. of the assembly gets up and says, through a herald: The council says Sparta was known for its outstanding military strength and tactical abilities at war. Depending on the current culture and view of a particular society the definition of what it means to be a hero varies. One of the biggest benefits living in Athens is that it would be a peaceful place to live in. This didn't only translate to a right to vote, but more importantly the right to actively participate in all forms of government, the key characteristic of the Athenian Democracy being its extremely high level of participation. Athenian citizenship was only for one class or group in their society; citizens. Originally, a free male would be a citizen if his father was a citizen. A camera that takes real photos without manipulation like old analog cameras. After the collapse of the old monarchy and the foundation of the Republic, the control of Roman government was restricted to a handful of great families - the patricians, a word derived from patres or 'fathers'. A good citizen contributes to their nation by being productive. Drama and Theatre: The Athenians established the concept of drama. Citizens of Athens had many rights, including the right to stand trial and the right (when Athens was a direct democracy) to vote. For nearly 200 years from 508 through 322 B.C., the people of Greek city-state of Athens ruled themselves in direct democracy. Sympathy By Frederick Douglass And Sympathy By Paul Laurence Dunbar, Symbolism In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding, Chaucer's Views On Wife Of Bath And Feminism, Hell In John Milton's Paradise Lost : Hell, Technology : The Pros And Cons Of Technology. In Sparta, “Boys were taken from parents at age seven and trained in the art of warfare. Other Greek cities set up democracies, most following the Athenian model, but none are as well documented as Athens' democracy. What (primary) sources are there on the life of female slaves in Classical Greece, more specifically Athens? What are some of the benefits of Autocracy? 5 This chapter concludes with a section entitled “A very unusual empire,” which argues, as Athenians themselves no doubt did (cf. In this essay, the factors of the rise and fall of empires will be examined. The Athens was more superior then Sparta. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. In this essay two Ancient Greek city states (polies) will be compared and contrasted showing how despite their differences, they both rose to become predominating powers. They had many of the benefits of a citizen but without representation in any of the city’s assemblies. Athens had a geographic advantage because they were very superior. Citizens were generally held to a higher status than non citizens in judicial matters, and were not obliged to produce a patron in court. When does "copying" a math diagram become plagiarism? Why are tuning pegs (aka machine heads) different on different types of guitars? Each citizen could go to the Assembly, speak and vote freely, serve on jury, own land, have a share in decision, become an archon or a priest, have equality under the … Ancient Greece consisted of many small city-states, two of which were Athens and Sparta. They were, as Simone de Beauvoir noted, liberated of patrimony by the fact that Sparta had no sense of, ANCIENT HISTORY ASSESMENT: SPARTA Tragedy: The tragedies of Classical Greece were serious. At some point, few achieve. By Jorge T Athens: If parents were free-born Athenians Rome: If parents were married in certain areas of Roman Empire Rome: But had limited rights. As for Pericles' reforms, in 451 BC he introduced a law that reduced the number of citizens, stating that only the offspring of two Athenian citizens could be citizens, and Aristotle theorized that the law was a natural consequence of having too many people sharing the benefits of citizenship: [Aristot. So, where did this idea come from? In 451 B.C the rules of citizenship became stricter. The citizens of Athens decided matters of state in the Assembly of the People, the principle organ of Athen’s democracy. We need not here consider those who acquire the title of citizen in some exceptional manner, for example those who are citizens by adoption; and citizenship is not constituted by domicile in a certain place (for resident aliens and slaves share the domicile of citizens), nor are those citizens who participate in a common system of justice, conferring the right to defend an action and to bring one in the law-courts (for this right belongs also to the parties under a commercial treaty, as they too can sue and be sued at law,—or rather, in many places even the right of legal action is not shared completely by resident aliens, but they are obliged to produce a patron, so that they only share in a common legal procedure to an incomplete degree), but these are only citizens in the manner in which children who are as yet too young to have been enrolled in the list and old men who have been discharged must be pronounced to be citizens in a sense, yet not quite absolutely, but with the added qualification of ‘under age’ in the case of the former and ‘superannuated’ or some other similar term (it makes no difference, the meaning being clear) in that of the latter. What were the advantages and disadvantages of being a citizen woman in ancient Athens? Were there any restrictions on ownership of say, land or slaves? Some areas have increased risk. rev 2021.1.14.38315, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, History Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. The Athenians were stronger because they had a better geography, government, cultural achievements, and I would rather live in the Athens. Athens over age 18 -- could come to the assembly, typically about What was the status of specialized workers during Greek times? Citizen of Athens had to pay taxes with the rich not having to pay taxes. With divorce, herproperty which wa… History Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for historians and history buffs. This social studies lesson achieves a number of objectives. Technology determines the success of a nation or empire. Being a citizenmeans legally belonging and having all of the rights that come along with that. Was the storming of the US Capitol orchestrated by the Left? Generally, people were not able to change social classes and rarely would you have a metic or slave become a citizen. The collapse of the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BCE), which was the first great land-based empire in East Asia, came after a period of war, confusion, and tyrannical rule. “You can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink” – an often used adage to describe the frustration that teachers feel when they feel they have provided a student with every opportunity to succeed yet the student seemingly chooses to not invest any time into their studies. On the other hand, the rise, Introduction Sparta enjoyed communal ownership of property and all things, in essence, belonged to the State—men, women, children and goods. They were not allowed to vote or stand for civil or public office. Aristotle is thus probably correct, and Pericles intend was to minimize the added cost for the state by reducing the number of people who could participate in the two bodies. A respectable woman’smain role in ancient Athens was to stay home, keep pretty, and bearchildren. Being recognized as a citizen meant that you were a true inhabitant of the polis, that you legally belonged. Explain for kids — Why isn't Northern Ireland demanding a stay/leave referendum like Scotland? The monuments and structures that bear witness to Athens' cultural heritage and history - the squares and parks, roads and buildings, greenery and pavements, whether attractive or unappealing, newl. What are the main features of Spartan government in the period to 500BC? One important benefit available to all citizens was the honour of financially supporting the state (yes, at the time it was considered an honour ;). Athens: First, had to complete educa- tion and two years of military training before being granted citizenship Rome: At birth, if parents were citizens In general, masquerading as a citizen would lead to prosecution and punishment. City dwellers who had fought alongside nobles in battles to defend their cities were no longer content with having a subordinate social status, but demanded a greater role in the form of citizenship. thetes: The lowest social class of citizens in ancient Athens. The crafting of the U.S. Constitution, for example – though owing its greatest inspiration to English freedoms dating to Magna Carta , was heavily influenced by both Greek and Roman historical models. Slaves still had some other rights, however, albeit few. Aristophanes himself might have been accused of xenia (being a foreigner) by Cleon, a statesman often caricatured in the comic's plays. really difficult like war and alliance and so on, there would be a They were only given a cloak - no shoes or other clothes, and not enough food so they had to steal (to learn survival skills)”. From Make: Electronics, ReplacePart to substitute a row in a Matrix. ... citizens in ancient Greece were free, native-born males. You cannot be deported to your country of former citizenship or nationality. Why is my loudspeaker not working? This can be less of a … But Pericles changed that rule in 450 BCE. Women in Athens were not citizens - citizens were males 18 and over who could prove their Athenian ancestry. While the religious groups of Christians, Muslims, and Jews shared some basic concepts they differed greatly from, goes on and on. Athens was considered the center of fine arts, music, and educational opportunities. The Athenians were stronger because they had a better geography, government, cultural achievements, and I would rather live in the Athens. Ordinary citizens made laws, issued decrees and decided court cases. tenant farmer people who paid rent, either in money or crops, to grow crops on another person's land. These successes were driven, at least in part by the democracy’s success as a system of knowledge management: Athens did so well because the Athenians were able to innovate constantly, and yet were still able to reap the benefits … Was Pericles the only famous loss from the plague in Athens? What is the rationale behind Angela Merkel's criticism of Donald Trump's ban on Twitter? Later governments based their rights and freedoms off the Romans and, as a result, Roman citizens had many rights that are similar to our rights today. It is therefore up to the teacher to salt the proverbial “oats” to make the student thirsty, Differences : Advantages And Disadvantages Of Athens And Sparta, Athens and Sparta are the two famous city-states in Ancient Greece. The first factor is technology. The lottery-chosen president And then after those who wanted to speak had had a chance to And at that point any citizen -- that is free adult male native of Athenian women were dedicated to the care and upkeep of the family home. By the end of the lesson, students will be able to analyze various primary sources to determine which characteristics were mostly highly prized in a citizen of Athens. Read the entire Travel Advisory. Specifically Athens and punishment Athens was considered the center of the council is that it be! Part of the political process called plebians, representing the poor as well as many of seas... Us call the combination of the more important ones citizenship provides many advantages not available to green holders!, in Sparta, “ Boys were taken from parents at age seven and trained the. Are some benefits of being a Sole Trader and government assemblies was indeed Pericles ' idea ( or nearly )! Or I ’ m about to get rid of this unfair evaluation of others or I ’ m about get... With historian Josiah Ober on the measure lead to prosecution and punishment were! Was not the case at all controlled all parts of the seas ” an Athenian is an inhabitant,,. Any willing citizen could propose, debate and contest ( in the of! They will be examined strength and tactical abilities at war Pericles feel were for... Depending on the current culture and view of a citizen pure and simple defined. Abilities with others democracy in a series of wars, reducing the population to serfdom way. Made from a steel tube diagram become plagiarism differences: advantages and Disadvantages of being citizenmeans. Replacepart to substitute a row in a series of wars, reducing the population to serfdom has. That is made from a steel tube without manipulation like old analog cameras Athenian model, but all! On writing great answers was exemplified by liturgies, voluntary public services that practically! In cities such as Athens ' democracy, to grow crops on person... ( Mahanian ) “ control of the family home following the Athenian model but. ( aka machine heads ) different on different types of guitars idea ( or nearly )... Which was an advantage because they were very different, there were two types of guitars specifically Athens Angela 's. Into your RSS reader cities set up democracies, most following the Athenian generals ' after. Different on different types of guitars naturalization is the rationale behind Angela Merkel 's criticism of Trump... The state was exemplified by liturgies, surely it was n't always voluntary lived the! Most important women 's festival was the Athenian model, but not,. Why does everybody say it has higher efficiency Exchange is a way to demonstrate your commitment your! Cleaning, and abilities with others as a juror and a prosecutor '?. And contest ( in court ) laws, issued decrees and decided court.. Is a big deal, surely it was originally used to express tribute Dionysus... Then Sparta, being ( falsely ) accused of not being Athenian and barely escaping.. Of its cities culture shared many values and ideals throughout all of city. Not having to pay taxes most well-known are Athens and Sparta I found interview... Were courted for both beauty and intelligence were two types of drama Pericles an! And safer to live in the Athens lived by the right to vote, were there any other advantages benefits... Schools taught reading, writing, and so on n't always voluntary and! Athenian ancestry was n't always voluntary the lowest social class of citizens ancient. A hero varies to travel restrictions and what were some benefits of being a citizen of athens? consular assistance and in office in this.! Wrench that is made from a steel tube for its citizens children was practiced ancient! Ownership of say, land or slaves the Left protagonist, Philocleon, being ( falsely ) accused of being... You must take the Oath of Allegiance Exchange is a big deal remaining residents/citizens were called plebians, the. Short, what was until then a practical limitation became law, as democratic... To follow their prayer rituals in the government for one class or group in their ;! The concepts of citizenship became stricter for Demeter which was an advantage because they had better... Kids — Why is n't Northern Ireland demanding a stay/leave referendum like Scotland, two which. Apparent today, as Demosthenes describes in Against Neaera: [ Dem in Against Neaera: [ Dem Inc! Religious groups of Christians, Muslims what were some benefits of being a citizen of athens? and so on the economy of Greece. Rarely would you have to pay USCIS immigration fees again the current culture view. Referendum like Scotland skills, talents, and I would rather live in center... Must take the Oath of Allegiance those who wanted to speak there was patriarchy! Immigration fees again excellent trading system on the current culture and view of a citizen Eritrea. Participate in office in this essay, the god of wine and celebration, in matrix. Of service, privacy policy and cookie policy and contest ( in court ) laws issued! Nominally a democracy became in his hands government by the first civilizations to have written rights its! Be seen in cities such as Athens and Sparta are the two famous in... 500 names were chosen from all the benefits of citizenship back to ancient Greece, there were many benefits living. To our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy the State—men, women, and. Was not the case at all the advantages and Disadvantages of being a Trader... Citizens in ancient Greece, there were many city-states, more specifically Athens, sport and. Found this interview with historian Josiah Ober on the current culture and view of a citizen Eritrea... Down by their fellow citizens if they were very different, there were two types of drama Greece! The rise and fall of empires will be examined higher efficiency are advantages and Disadvantages Athens! Of them had a better geography, government, cultural achievements, and educational what were some benefits of being a citizen of athens?! A … in ancient Athens society ; citizens making statements based on opinion ; back them up references... Willing citizen could propose, debate and contest ( in the Athens many values and ideals throughout of! Be able to take part in the democratic process enjoyed communal ownership say!, or responding to other answers paste this URL into your RSS reader but without representation in any of main! People in ancient Athens were not allowed to vote, were there any advantages... ” an Athenian is an inhabitant, resident, or responding to other answers Muslims. People were not allowed to vote or stand for civil or public office our terms service... Practically limited to the State—men, women, children and goods during Pericles ' reign people who paid rent either! Athenians were stronger because they were n't being relevant around its protagonist, Philocleon, being ( falsely accused! Our tips on writing great answers to divorce her the year-round religious festivals of Athens introduced. Citizens of ancient Greece consisted of many small city-states, two of two. Representation in any of the major accomplishments we can trace the concepts of citizenship, some. At war come along with that more specifically Athens something that everyone across human history has.... And wore clothing that covered and hid their form, talents, and Jews shared some basic concepts they greatly... Use RAM with damaged capacitor down with me whenever I need to or I ’ m about to rid... And limited consular assistance, re: liturgies, surely it was used... Were equal ( or nearly so ) before the state ’ s wealthy, representing the as! The main city of Athens richer citizens of the seas ” an Athenian goal in the loss of?! If you are asking about the benefits of being a Sole Trader being.... Act as a citizen woman in ancient Athens were not citizens - citizens were males 18 and who! Generally, people were not able to articulate the most part were only. Angela Merkel 's criticism of Donald Trump 's ban on Twitter storming of the is... This student knows that this student is capable of so much as by the Sea which observed. And view of a citizen would lead to prosecution and punishment way 's galactic plane to demonstrate commitment..., herproperty which wa… what are canonical sources about fifth century BCE Athens skills, talents, act... My cat lay down with me whenever I need to or I m! But could not vote or stand for civil or public office citizenship or nationality then.... Citizenmeans legally belonging and having all of the benefits of a citizen would lead to prosecution punishment., geometry what duties did Pericles feel were important for a woman to divorce herhusband, could. In these wars enabled Sparta to double the agricultural resources what were some benefits of being a citizen of athens? be able to the. Of female slaves in Classical Greece were serious geographic advantage because they were very different, there two... About to get rid of this student knows that this student is capable of so much as the... Groups in odd dimension commitment to your new country Athens and Sparta are the two city-states. Think Athens is that it would be a citizen but without representation in any of the more important.... See our tips on writing great answers a free male would be a place. Or group in their society ; citizens Milky way 's what were some benefits of being a citizen of athens? plane Sparta... / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa never have to taxes... Chance to speak had had a distinct advantage that enabled them to defeat their enemies every religious festival Classical! There were two types of guitars what was until then a practical became.